How Toyota Got the 2024 Land Cruiser So Wrong — Full Review & History

by john
New Toyota Land Cruiser in America: A Legacy Compromised or Reinvented?

Explore the latest Toyota Land Cruiser in America, its modern hybrid engine, and how it stacks up against its legendary predecessors and the refined Lexus GX. Read our in-depth analysis of performance, ride quality, and off-road capability.

Toyota enthusiasts have long revered the Land Cruiser nameplate for its uncompromising off-road capability, rugged reliability, and legendary durability. But the latest iteration of the Land Cruiser available in America has sparked a debate: does it live up to the iconic reputation of its predecessors, or has Toyota missed the mark?

A Legacy of Toughness – and a Tangled Family Tree

For decades, the Land Cruiser has symbolized unyielding strength. The legendary FJ40, built without compromise, once ruled off-road terrain, earning its status as America’s “stealth wealth SUV.” However, many fans may be surprised to learn that the Land Cruiser sold in America is just one branch on an enormous and complex family tree.

New Toyota Land Cruiser in America
How Toyota Got the 2024 Land Cruiser

Originally, Toyota’s off-roader began as the BJ prototype—developed for military use during the Korean War—before evolving into the FJ series. With continuous improvements, the FJ became the FJ20 and then the FJ40, setting standards that outclassed every competitor. Today, although the new Land Cruiser carries the same badge, its design and performance reflect a shift in priorities that may leave traditionalists questioning its place in the lineage.

Read more: Daa Duster vs. Toyota Land Cruiser Offroad – The Ultimate Off-Road Challenge

The American Model: Less Legendary, More Compromised?

When you compare the new Land Cruiser in America to the heavy-duty legends of old, the differences are stark:

  • Engine and Performance:
    The modern Land Cruiser is powered by a turbocharged four-cylinder hybrid engine—a significant departure from the old V8 powerhouses. Critics argue that this engine vibrates excessively in the 1,800 to 2,300 RPM range, sounding “like a dying calf” when pushed beyond its comfort zone. The addition of a hybrid battery further compromises both engine sound and cargo space, leaving many fans nostalgic for the raw, unfiltered power of earlier models.
  • Ride Quality and Refinement:
    Unlike its V8 predecessors that combined brute strength with effortless refinement, the new Land Cruiser feels truck-like and somewhat strained. Its interior may offer modern amenities, but it struggles to exude the luxury and effortless driving experience that made past models both tough and desirable.
  • Off-Road Capability:
    While the Land Cruiser still boasts body-on-frame construction, solid rear axles, and locking differentials—key elements that made it the go-to vehicle for extreme off-roading—it now competes in a market where vehicles like the Lexus GX offer nearly identical capability with a far more refined and comfortable experience.

Lexus GX: The Refined Counterpart

In a twist of irony, many American buyers might be better off opting for the Lexus GX instead of the new Land Cruiser. Though both vehicles share a similar DNA and are essentially built on the same platform, the GX offers:

  • Superior Ride Comfort:
    The Lexus GX rides smoother and feels less stressed under normal driving conditions, making it ideal for both off-road adventures and daily commutes.
  • Enhanced Interior Quality:
    With better materials, refined finishes, and more sophisticated infotainment systems, the GX delivers an experience that is unmistakably premium—a stark contrast to the sometimes “cheap” feel of the new Land Cruiser’s interior.
  • Effortless Driving Dynamics:
    While the Land Cruiser has always been about indestructibility and utility, the Lexus GX strikes a balance between toughness and luxury. It manages to be powerful yet quiet, refined yet capable—traits that many modern buyers prioritize.

A Marketing Mess of Epic Proportions

Over the past 50 years, Toyota’s handling of the Land Cruiser branding in America has been a lesson in missed opportunities. The rugged, no-nonsense image of the original models has been diluted by compromises in performance and design. While the Land Cruiser remains a symbol of reliability, its current incarnation may leave enthusiasts feeling that they’re not getting what they once loved. In contrast, the Lexus GX successfully captures that timeless balance of capability and comfort, arguably making it the better choice in today’s market.

Read more: BMW M340i Stage 3 Build: Pure 800 Turbo, Dyno Results, and Exhaust Nightmares

Final Verdict: Tough but Not Timeless

The new Toyota Land Cruiser in America embodies both the heritage and the compromises of modern automotive design. It carries the legacy of indestructibility but struggles to match the effortless refinement that once defined the model. For those who demand the raw, uncompromised off-road prowess of the past, the new Land Cruiser may seem like a pale imitation. Meanwhile, the Lexus GX emerges as a more attractive option—offering similar capability with far better comfort and a more luxurious driving experience.

Ultimately, if you’re in search of a vehicle that can tow, traverse rough terrain, and reliably get you home with your family intact, the new Land Cruiser still holds value. But if you crave a blend of rugged capability and refined luxury, you might be better served by the Lexus GX.

In a market where history meets modernity, the Land Cruiser remains a symbol of endurance—even if its current form has left some fans longing for the glory days. What’s your take on the new Land Cruiser? Share your thoughts in the comments below.

Leave a Comment